Of course it wouldn’t . I was simply stating surprise that wrinkleyowlie thought the gear change to be very slick whereas MCN kid thought it the opposite .
The MCN kid is bound to think that.....along with most bike mag chimps.
They're fed a diet of Jap bikes, and mostly sport type Jap bikes....all of which have geared clutches turning at least twice crank speed....hence they're used to grabbing gears quickly, bam, bam, bam.
The crank mounted clutch on the Guzzi, just like in Airhead and Oilhead BMWs, needs a subtler and ever so more deliberate change than that.....just a bit more compassion and understanding.
If the chimps and kids from the magazines actually used the bike, lived with it and went away for several days on it, they would most likely learn to understand the bike.
Always read these thrash tests with a bucket of salt, never mind a pinch of it, and never take the words of a journo as totally accurate gospel.....you're only reading an opinion anyway.