Test ride on the 1250 this afternoon.
My feedback for what it's worth.
Engine: Brilliant. I found myself riding around a gear up...4th instead of 3rd etc. Took the bike to 25mph in 6th....didn't like it much but pulled well out of it.
Pops wheelies very easily compared to the 1200. Obviously this is essential info.
Brisk riding happens very easily now. But smoothly. As has already been mentioned the bike is now deceptively fast. As an example...my old 1200 Hilltop'd LC GSA - at 50 mph I would probably drop a gear to 3rd for an overtake if it was a bit tight. Just in case. This new engine, without a Hilltop map, you could easily leave it in 4th and just gun the throttle. Pulls very smoothly with the extra torque. 6th gear at 60mph, whack the throttle and you're doing 90mph very quickly. You get the idea.
I think a Hilltop map on the 1250 motor would be pretty awesome actually, but let's not have a Hilltop thread. If you hold the throttle at 2-3k revs you still have some lumpy lumpy, which would be sorted with Hilltop I expect, but in truth, riding the bike you never feel it. I wish my 1290 S was as smooth that's for sure and I'm more than content with the throttle on the KTM.
Some small points in no particular order.
The quick shifter and blipper - a bit jerky compared to the 1290. Not sure why. Might need calibrating but there were some real pauses using the shifter that threw me back and forth on the bike at gear changes. Not every change of course, but more than I was expecting as the one on my old 14 plate GS was fine.
Gearbox - tight. You had to give it a good pull to change gear with the blipper. Probably just needs running in a bit more (600 odd miles on the odo).
Levers - liked those.
Exhaust - quiet. I actually quite liked it but imagine it will be too quiet for some.
Road noise from the front end - too much of it. Might be tyres but equally might not be.
No recall bushes on the top of the shocks....it looks like the pre-fix bikes so I guess they've changed the design to resolve that??
Stock screen - I'm 5'9". Found it fine up to 90 on the dual-carriageway in lowest setting, hardly any helmet shake at all. Better than my 14! Ironically, when I put the screen up to the high setting there was way more buffeting. So for me the high setting would be for rain.
As always, the GS was super stable at all times/speeds.
A comparison to the 1290 S:
Buttons! I've always loved the GS buttons for everything. Heated grips? Button. ABS/Wheelie mode? Button for that. You get the picture. The menu system on the KTM is great, but I prefer the GS setup.
The dash? I think I prefer the GS dash. Just. Mostly because the contrast is great and I struggle to see some of the words on the KTM screen these days
The fit & finish. I think I'm going to award both bikes 4 stars. Neither bike looks like a 5*.
The GS has heavier steering at speed and needs good pressure to weave for example. Slow speed manners are fine. The bike has loads of power now but to use the power in fast twisty's needs more effort than the 1290 - which goes where you look almost without you realising you're making inputs. This is my opinion from 2 1/2hrs, suggest you try it with your riding style as you may not agree.
Suspension - I tried all the settings. My opinion? Not as well set up as the 1290. I aimed for some rough road and sometimes couldn't help hit some dips in the tarmac. I didn't like it. This is the biggest issue from the ride for me. In 'road' setting it was too bouncy. In Dynamic I would say it rides very well, but is harsh when you hit the rough stuff. It feels like it needs the rebound damping adjusting, but you can't adjust it. The 1290 can be left in Sport mode all day long - it's a firm ride, but doesn't create discomfort.
The GS, to 'me', is a cruiser Adv bike. Wide bars. In 'Road' mode, if you don't push on and like to float around doing 60mph, I think you'll be fine with the 1250. I suspect loaded with luggage the GS would be a bit more comfortable but I couldn't test that. The 1290 IS comfortable when loaded....FACT.
The 1290 or the GS then? What's my conclusion?
Well, I think if you love your current GS, you'll REALLY love the new one. I was immediately at home on it. The new engine is very nice indeed. Smooth, linear power. Fast. Not uncomfortable.
I actually like the gold wheel model in the flesh and I would have that one for sure.
There's a 'but' though. And the 'but', for me, is that the GS just seems too...I don't know how to put it. Struggling for words. If I say boring...that's just rubbish. But it's not exciting to ride like the KTM - I know I've said this before so I guess I should shut up. The new GS is brilliant, it really is. But it's not a 1290 S. If I looked at both bikes next to each other in my garage it'd be the Orange bike that would make me grin. So I'm sticking with my Kato for now.
I certainly think everyone should test ride the 1250. I'd be interested in your opinions of it to be honest.