absolute twaddle, everyone on here is an expert in all things tyre related.I've had the same opinion for some time. You only have to read a few posts in any tyre thread where someone will claim whatever tyre it is are absolutely the dogs bollocks, grippiest things ever, and someone else will claim they are total ditchfinders made out of wood.
I reckon in a blind test, for road riding, most riders would have absolutely no clue what tyre was fitted, even whether it was a pure road tyre or a mild trail type.
If one of the leading members says its true, it is. If you disagree a keen mod or other members of the inner sanctum will be along to bully you into their way of thinking.